Most countries of the world used to get more stuff from the United States than they did from China. But now it’s the other way around. Now most countries buy more stuff from China.
This map, which has been making the rounds of the Internet, appeared in the Financial Times—behind a paywall, unfortunately for me, because I don’t subscribe to the FT.
Many economists think the turning point was in 2001 when China joined the World Trade Organization, which included the world’s most advanced industrial nations.
China became entitled to “most favored nation” status, which means no trade barrier against a WTO member could be higher than a barrier against any other member.
I say China’s gains had to do with the effectiveness of China’s industrial policy, and the lack of any U.S. industrial policy.
China told foreign nations that if they wish to sell goods in China, they would have to locate manufacturing facilities in China. Furthermore they would have to share their technological know-how with Chinese partners. Then the Chinese would take their new knowledge, improve on it, and use it o compete with their former partners.
The U.S. government, under Bill Clinton, George W. Bush and Barack Obama, was content to let this happen. American consumers benefitted from cheap imports, and stockholders in American companies shared the profits of offshoring.
Meanwhile the United States dissipated its wealth in waging pointless and inconclusive foreign wars, while China used its wealth to make itself stronger.
Unlike his predecessors, Donald Trump has correctly identified terms of trade with China as a problem. He deserved credit for putting this issue on the table.
But his scattershot tariffs on Chinese goods do not solve the problem. All they do is to create a market for goods from other low-wage countries.
The Chinese government successfully executed a long-range plan to build up its industrial strength, using subsidies but also building up the infrastructure and know-how of the nation as a whole.
The U.S. government has no plan. It has been content to stand aside and allow financiers to hollow out U.S. manufacturing. Tariffs aren’t an answer unless they are part of an overall strategy to rebuild.
The Chinese aren’t to blame for our problems. Our leaders are to blame for our problems. We are to blame for our leaders.
LINKS
The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new master by Barry C. Lynn for Harper’s magazine.
How Bill Clinton and American financiers armed China by Matt Stoller for BIG.
China Revolutionizes World Trade While Washington Dozes by Geoffrey Aronson for The American Conservative.