A lot is being written about neoconservatives and how they are to blame for America’s forever wars. But who are they?
‘Neoconservative’ is not just a fancy word for “warmonger” or “war hawk.” Neoconservatism is a coherent set of ideas that people sincerely believe and are working hard to promote.
That’s why the neocons have such influence. Both elites and millions of Americans are sold on their ideas, or, rather, they just take them for granted.
The essence of neoconservatism is as follows:
- The United States of America is the embodiment of democracy and freedom.
- U.S. American power is a force for good and supreme U.S. American power is a supreme good.
- The USA, after its victory over Soviet Russia, found itself in a position of supreme power.
- Anything or anyone that threatens this power is bad, and deserves to be suppressed by whatever means necessary.
- The USA has the power to accomplish anything its leaders have the will to see through.
- If the USA is ever defeated, it is because of weakness of will, lack of unity or treason, not the lack of the means to win.
- Anyone who undermines American morale, whatever their motive, is, objectively speaking, an enemy.
You may think all this seems extreme, but there are individuals in the U.S. government and foreign policy establishment who literally believe all these things, many who believe in a weak form of these principles and few if any who would contradict them altogether.
They constitute a network journalists, academics, foreign policy and national security officials and a few politicians, all working together to promote their views and help each other advance.
Outright opponents of their views are few. Dissenters include the so-called “paleo-conservatives” and economic nationalists such as Pat Buchanan, who opposed intervention in Iraq and now think the United States should tend to its own problems rather than trying to reorder the world.
They also include the “realists” such as Henry Kissinger, who was ruthless in playing the Great Power game, but recognized that there were limits as to what American power can accomplish.
I think the insiders who leak information to Seymour Hersh are in this category. They don’t necessarily object to American foreign policy overall. They just object to stupid and unproductive things, such as blowing up the Nord Stream pipelines.
But nobody in a position of influence advocates peace as a goal. Even Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and other self-described progressive Democrats are silent.
The result is never-ending war. This cannot go on forever and is bound to end in a bad way.