THE DERRICK BELL READER edited by Richard Delgado and Jean Stefanic (2005)
I’ve been reading up on critical race theory to prepare for a presentation I’m going to do Sept. 21 at a Zoom meeting at First Universalist Church of Rochester, N.Y.
At the time I agreed to do the presentation, I’d read a college textbook called Critical Race Theory: an Introduction.
I thought I understood the topic reasonably well, although I was turned off by the authors’ rejection of ideas that I hold hear—liberalism, universalism, the possibility of solidarity across racial lines.
Since then I’ve been reading more about the topic, and especially works of the late Derrick A. Bell Jr., who is considered the father of this school of thought.
Although I haven’t changed my mind about CRT, I have come to respect Bell and take his ideas and the ideas of his followers more seriously than before.
Bell had a distinguished career as a civil rights lawyer for the U.S. government and the NAACP Legal Defense Fund, and a second distinguished career as a law school professor, scholar and writer.
Bell was the first African-American to be a tenured professor at Harvard Law School. He resigned in 1992 in protest against Harvard’s failure to hire a black woman as a tenured law school professor.
The video above shows young Barack Obama, then a Harvard law school student, speaking at a protest in support of Prof. Bell. The video then segues into a review of Bell’s life.
Bell thought that racism is baked into the white American mind. The only times that African-Americans advance is when these advances benefit elite white people, and such advances are small and temporary. He said black people should protest racial inequality, not because there is a realistic hope that it will be overcome, but for the sake of self-respect and honor.
Some of the most interesting parts of The Derrick Bell Reader are a series of fantastic stories, or parables, illustrating his ideas and feelings. They are not proof of anything, but they are windows into his mind. They are thought experiments. You are invited to think about them and decide whether you agree.
###
The Chronicle of the Space Traders
In this story, extraterrestrials land on the East Coast on Jan. 1 and offer the USA a bargain. They will provide the means to solve the USA’s international trade, pollution and energy problems. In return, they ask one thing: the nation’s African-American population. The country is given 16 days to decide.
There are some objections. Black Americans are a cheap labor force, but also a market for U.S. business. More importantly, they serve as a target for the resentments of poor and working-class whites, which might otherwise be targeted a white elites.
But the benefits of the trade to white America outweigh the benefits. A Constitutional amendment is rushed through, and, on Martin Luther King Day, the USA’s black population leave the country the same way their ancestors arrived, naked and in chains.
Bell said that when he tells this story to his law classes, almost all his students, both black and white, agree that US Americans would make the trade.