I read The White Nationalist Manifesto by Greg Johnson partly because I am annoyed at the casual way the word “racist” is thrown around, and I thought it would be interesting to discuss the ideas of an actual unapologetic racist.
I read it partly because I can remember when white racist ideas such as his were acceptable, and I see nothing in the nature of things to prevent them from becoming acceptable again.
And I read it partly because, as John Stuart Mill once said, “he who knows only his own side of a case knows little of that.” If I believe in equal rights for all, I should be willing to confront the strongest arguments of someone who believes the opposite.
I take Greg Johnson’s arguments seriously and will respond to them in a civil manner. I hope nobody accuses me of being an apologist for white nationalism because I do not use abusive language.. An insult is not an argument..
Greg Johnson starts out with the assumption that there is a genetic difference between white and non-white people that is so fundamental that they cannot live together in peace. He then goes on to point out two facts.
- The birth rate in majority-white countries, including the USA, is below the replacement rate (an average of 2.1 per woman).
- All the countries in which the birth rate is above the replacement rate are non-white. These are the countries that would be the predominant sources of immigration.
If non-white immigration and the declining birth rate continue indefinitely, white people will in time become minorities in their homelands and possibly be replaced altogether. That’s a matter of logic. Johnson calls this “white genocide.”
He mentioned the recent rise in “deaths of despair” (suicide, drug overdoses, alcohol-related liver disease) among the American white population, which he attributed to the stress of living in a multi-racial society.
He believes that two things are necessary to prevent this:
- White women of child-bearing age must have at least three children. To ensure this happens, feminism must be rejected, abortion and birth control outlawed and LGBT persons not tolerated—at least among white people. Men should be protectors and providers, women should be wives and mothers.
- Immigration from non-white countries must cease and, over time, non-white immigrants and their children be returned to their homelands. Jews should be sent to Israel. In majority-white countries outside Europe, separate territories should be provided for indigenous peoples and “perhaps” for descendants of non-white slaves. Aside from this, the long-range goal is to get rid of the non-white people.
Johnson distinguished white nationalism from white supremacy. He did not advocate that white people subjugate and rule people of color, as in the pre-Civil War American South or apartheid South Africa. He rather wants to exclude people of color as much as possible.
He also distinguished white nationalism from German Naziism and Italian Fascism, but here he had to tread carefully because neo-Nazis are part of his constituency. He praised the Nazis and Fascists, whom he calls the Old Right, for their racism and anti-semitism, but added that white nationalism does not require a totalitarian police state or wars of extermination.
But while while nationalism is not totalitarian, neither is it a philosophy of individual freedom. Johnson wrote:
White nationalism by its very nature is statist rather than libertarian, collectivist rather than individualist, illiberal rather than liberal. We believe there is a common good—the survival and flourishing of our people—which can only be promoted by government policy, and we believe that whenever private interests conflict with the common good, the common good should win out.
Johnson endorsed the basic idea of identity politics as he sees it—that you should stick up for members of your own ethnic and racial group, regardless of merit or the facts of the individual case.. White nationalism is identity politics for white people.
The last thing he wants is a colorblind society, in which African-Americans, Hispanics and other non-whites assimilate and intermarry with the majority population.